Re: Evil Nanotech Howie Goodell (goodell@mediaone.net)
Search tool
Fri, 25 Jun 1999 15:20:11 GMT

>And if the MNT capable nut instead of attacking directly, builds >something that seeks out a poorly defended energy source, makes 100 >times the MASS of defense system you have, and simply smothers it?

MASS is the key. For most of history, warfare consisted of two groups of people hacking at each other, and the *more numerous* one (with some allowance for weapons and tactics) stood over the heap of corpses at the end and claimed victory. The scary thing about technology, nano in particular, is what I call "the disproportion of means and ends": one man's finger on the nuclear launch button; a few vials of virus and some plane tickets; releasing a single "gray goo" replicator -- and it's all over for everybody.

We need to take the threat of nano warfare seriously. Providing we do, there's no cause for despair, because,

IT'S THE MASS, STUPID!

I want to live surrounded by nanites; so everything around me behaves just as I want it to. Even the dirt in my front yard will aerate itself, fall cleanly off my feet, etc.

Whatever its job, each of my nanites has a "Swiss Army" program: "disassemble any unfamiliar nanites and sound an alarm." Because my "benign swarm" permeates every object I own including me, my furniture, trees, etc.; there won't be "poorly-defended energy sources." So if you want to goo me, you'll need to transport a really large MASS of replicators to my vicinity, and finish the job before the people and robots around me swamp them. You'd do better with a gun!

Even if you do me in, the alarm will circle the planet before you disassemble my epidermis. A local replicator attack will be just that: local. "Madman Kills Neighbor with Goo." Every object on the planet will swarm with nanites, and each object and its nanites will have a registered owner, with dust-mote cops checking their IDs and configurations by the second. Remember large-scale goods distribution will be almost extinct; there won't be excuses for distributing mass quantities of anything. (Insidious possibility: it's a design downloaded to your own household assembler; we'll need virus checkers, etc.) Remember,

IT'S THE MASS, STUPID!